1 00:00:02,469 --> 00:00:04,838 [pop music playing indistinctly] 2 00:00:04,904 --> 00:00:07,440 - One margherita, one meat lover's, 3 00:00:07,507 --> 00:00:10,210 and one mushroom with pineapple, 4 00:00:10,276 --> 00:00:11,711 which should be illegal. 5 00:00:11,778 --> 00:00:13,413 - I'll shoot them a really dirty look for you 6 00:00:13,480 --> 00:00:14,781 when I drop them off. 7 00:00:14,848 --> 00:00:16,616 - Ah. Would you? 8 00:00:16,683 --> 00:00:17,584 Hey. 9 00:00:17,650 --> 00:00:18,952 Shutting down the phone soon. 10 00:00:19,018 --> 00:00:21,087 Should be your last run. You wanna come over after? 11 00:00:21,154 --> 00:00:22,622 - I don't know. 12 00:00:22,689 --> 00:00:24,190 Are you gonna let me pick the movie this time? 13 00:00:24,257 --> 00:00:26,192 - Oh, I thought you liked the horror movie marathon. 14 00:00:26,259 --> 00:00:27,660 You liked "Cabin in the Woods." 15 00:00:27,727 --> 00:00:30,196 - I liked Chris Hemsworth. 16 00:00:30,263 --> 00:00:31,197 - Ouch. 17 00:00:31,264 --> 00:00:32,465 - I'm kidding. 18 00:00:32,531 --> 00:00:34,501 Yeah, I'd be up for a movie night. 19 00:00:34,567 --> 00:00:36,002 Might take me an hour, though. 20 00:00:36,069 --> 00:00:37,537 These deliveries are all over. 21 00:00:37,604 --> 00:00:39,439 - No rush. I'll be here. 22 00:00:43,710 --> 00:00:45,678 - I'll call you when I'm on my way back. 23 00:00:45,745 --> 00:00:46,679 - Mm-hmm. 24 00:00:51,518 --> 00:00:53,920 [indistinct chatter] 25 00:00:53,987 --> 00:00:57,023 [horns honking] [distant sirens wailing] 26 00:01:10,937 --> 00:01:13,840 [ominous music] 27 00:01:13,907 --> 00:01:20,847 ♪ ♪ 28 00:01:48,541 --> 00:01:51,211 - Hey, there you are. - Come see my new place. 29 00:01:51,277 --> 00:01:53,546 [indistinct chatter] 30 00:01:53,613 --> 00:02:00,720 ♪ ♪ 31 00:02:15,502 --> 00:02:17,837 - [screaming] 32 00:02:21,641 --> 00:02:27,480 ♪ ♪ 33 00:02:27,547 --> 00:02:28,548 - Thanks for coming all the way out. 34 00:02:28,615 --> 00:02:29,849 - Yeah, it's not a problem. 35 00:02:29,916 --> 00:02:31,117 We hear you have a possible abduction. 36 00:02:31,184 --> 00:02:33,219 - Yeah, we found the car early this morning. 37 00:02:33,286 --> 00:02:35,355 Registration came back to a pizza place in the city. 38 00:02:35,421 --> 00:02:36,823 Apparently, both the car and the driver 39 00:02:36,890 --> 00:02:38,725 were reported missing late last night. 40 00:02:38,791 --> 00:02:40,260 - What do you know about the driver? 41 00:02:40,326 --> 00:02:42,962 - 22-year-old delivery girl named Chloe Rogers. 42 00:02:43,029 --> 00:02:44,464 Guy who called it in said she went out for her last run 43 00:02:44,531 --> 00:02:45,698 a little before midnight. 44 00:02:45,765 --> 00:02:47,500 Never made any of her stops. 45 00:02:47,567 --> 00:02:48,868 Pizzas are still in the car. 46 00:02:48,935 --> 00:02:51,704 - All of her delivery addresses are within 47 00:02:51,771 --> 00:02:53,406 two miles of the pizza place. 48 00:02:53,473 --> 00:02:57,510 - So why the hell'd she end up an hour outside the city? 49 00:02:57,577 --> 00:02:58,945 Uh, you find any personal effects? 50 00:02:59,012 --> 00:03:00,179 Phone, ID, wallet? 51 00:03:00,246 --> 00:03:01,648 - No bag or wallet, but her cell phone 52 00:03:01,714 --> 00:03:03,016 was left in the cup holder. 53 00:03:05,051 --> 00:03:07,654 - Okay, let's get a K-9 unit to search the surrounding area. 54 00:03:07,720 --> 00:03:10,023 We could find a body somewhere out there. 55 00:03:10,089 --> 00:03:15,061 ♪ ♪ 56 00:03:15,128 --> 00:03:19,165 - OA, there's a secondary set of tire tracks. 57 00:03:19,232 --> 00:03:20,733 - Okay. Thank you. 58 00:03:25,104 --> 00:03:26,739 - All right, folks. Let's get into it. 59 00:03:26,806 --> 00:03:28,174 We have a missing persons case-- 60 00:03:28,241 --> 00:03:30,577 22-year-old Chloe Rogers, delivery driver 61 00:03:30,643 --> 00:03:32,545 for Luna Pizza in Chelsea. 62 00:03:32,612 --> 00:03:34,213 She left work driving the company car 63 00:03:34,280 --> 00:03:36,082 at around 11:55 p.m. 64 00:03:36,149 --> 00:03:38,484 Uh, the car was found this morning an hour away. 65 00:03:38,551 --> 00:03:39,786 The question is, where's Chloe? 66 00:03:39,852 --> 00:03:41,354 Was she with the car when it was abandoned, 67 00:03:41,421 --> 00:03:43,423 or was she carjacked before it even left the city? 68 00:03:43,489 --> 00:03:45,525 - Carjacking isn't a bad theory. 69 00:03:45,592 --> 00:03:48,962 ERT found damage on the car's passenger side door handle. 70 00:03:49,028 --> 00:03:50,630 Thinks someone was trying to break in with a screwdriver. 71 00:03:50,697 --> 00:03:52,231 - All right, that's-- that's something. 72 00:03:52,298 --> 00:03:54,100 - Although how many car thieves do you know 73 00:03:54,167 --> 00:03:56,603 wanna steal a pizza delivery vehicle? 74 00:03:56,669 --> 00:03:58,304 - Right. Have we heard from Maggie and OA? 75 00:03:58,371 --> 00:03:59,839 - Yeah, just talked to them. 76 00:03:59,906 --> 00:04:01,708 The area is pretty deserted, 77 00:04:01,774 --> 00:04:03,242 so they're not having much luck with witnesses. 78 00:04:03,309 --> 00:04:05,244 But they did send over footage from the gas station 79 00:04:05,311 --> 00:04:06,946 up the road. - Ooh. 80 00:04:07,013 --> 00:04:08,748 - Check this out. 81 00:04:08,815 --> 00:04:12,318 Timestamps puts this at 12:42 a.m. 82 00:04:12,385 --> 00:04:14,153 - Can you zoom in on that car? 83 00:04:20,192 --> 00:04:22,228 Well, that confirms the abduction theory. 84 00:04:22,295 --> 00:04:23,663 Can we get an ID from that? 85 00:04:23,730 --> 00:04:26,232 - Uh, no. It's too dark for facial rec. 86 00:04:26,299 --> 00:04:27,533 - Can we find another angle? 87 00:04:27,600 --> 00:04:28,568 Get him coming back the other way? 88 00:04:28,635 --> 00:04:30,003 - No, I checked. 89 00:04:30,069 --> 00:04:31,170 Wherever they went after ditching the car, 90 00:04:31,237 --> 00:04:32,639 they didn't pass the gas station again. 91 00:04:32,705 --> 00:04:34,807 - Okay, well, if the evidence won't help us, 92 00:04:34,874 --> 00:04:36,242 maybe the victim can. 93 00:04:36,309 --> 00:04:38,878 What do we know about her? - Uh, not a lot. 94 00:04:38,945 --> 00:04:40,813 We're actually having trouble finding information. 95 00:04:40,880 --> 00:04:42,582 We don't have an official ID yet, 96 00:04:42,649 --> 00:04:44,851 and there's no online presence. 97 00:04:44,917 --> 00:04:45,785 - Well, somebody's gotta know her. 98 00:04:45,852 --> 00:04:47,120 Who reported her missing? 99 00:04:47,186 --> 00:04:48,655 - Uh, a coworker from the pizza place. 100 00:04:48,721 --> 00:04:49,889 Ben Miller. 101 00:04:49,956 --> 00:04:51,658 Scola and Tiffany are talking to him now. 102 00:04:51,724 --> 00:04:53,960 [suspenseful music] 103 00:04:54,027 --> 00:04:56,429 - My dad hired Chloe to work with us about six months ago, 104 00:04:56,496 --> 00:04:59,465 and we started dating pretty soon after that. 105 00:04:59,532 --> 00:05:01,000 But she's a great girl, you know? 106 00:05:01,067 --> 00:05:02,669 I mean, she wouldn't just disappear like this. 107 00:05:02,735 --> 00:05:04,170 - Yeah. We're not doubting that. 108 00:05:04,237 --> 00:05:05,772 Can you tell us what happened last night? 109 00:05:05,838 --> 00:05:07,173 - Um, I don't know. 110 00:05:07,240 --> 00:05:08,708 She was supposed to be back after her run 111 00:05:08,775 --> 00:05:10,443 to drop the car off. 112 00:05:10,510 --> 00:05:12,745 When she wasn't back by 1:00, I started getting worried. 113 00:05:12,812 --> 00:05:14,447 - Okay, and you were here the whole time? 114 00:05:14,514 --> 00:05:15,915 Cameras will confirm that? 115 00:05:15,982 --> 00:05:17,817 - Yeah. 116 00:05:17,884 --> 00:05:19,719 What, you don't think I did anything to Chloe? 117 00:05:19,786 --> 00:05:20,653 - You were the last one to see her. 118 00:05:20,720 --> 00:05:21,854 We just have to ask. 119 00:05:21,921 --> 00:05:23,723 - Yeah, I get it, but I would never. 120 00:05:23,790 --> 00:05:25,558 Look, we haven't been together for a long time, 121 00:05:25,625 --> 00:05:27,326 but I really do care about her. 122 00:05:27,393 --> 00:05:29,328 - Good. Help us find her. 123 00:05:29,395 --> 00:05:30,797 - You know anything about her background? 124 00:05:30,863 --> 00:05:32,098 - What do you mean? 125 00:05:32,165 --> 00:05:33,332 - Well, we're having trouble tracking down 126 00:05:33,399 --> 00:05:34,734 her family, for one, 127 00:05:34,801 --> 00:05:36,135 so she ever say anything about them? 128 00:05:36,202 --> 00:05:38,171 - I think it was just her and her dad. 129 00:05:38,237 --> 00:05:39,739 But she didn't really talk about him a lot. 130 00:05:39,806 --> 00:05:41,674 I got the feeling they didn't have the best relationship. 131 00:05:41,741 --> 00:05:43,209 - How so? - I don't know. 132 00:05:43,276 --> 00:05:46,012 Any time I'd mention him, she'd just change the subject. 133 00:05:46,079 --> 00:05:48,748 I think she came to New York for a fresh start, you know? 134 00:05:48,815 --> 00:05:50,817 - Where was she from, originally? 135 00:05:50,883 --> 00:05:52,452 - Upstate, around Poughkeepsie. 136 00:05:52,518 --> 00:05:54,153 - You know her dad's name? 137 00:05:54,220 --> 00:05:56,956 - No. Sorry. 138 00:05:57,023 --> 00:05:58,958 - We're gonna do everything we can to track down Chloe, 139 00:05:59,025 --> 00:06:01,027 but we need more information. 140 00:06:01,094 --> 00:06:02,662 I mean, she worked for your dad, right? 141 00:06:02,729 --> 00:06:03,863 He must have some paperwork on her. 142 00:06:03,930 --> 00:06:06,332 A W-4 or a driver's license? 143 00:06:06,399 --> 00:06:07,834 - I don't--I don't think so. 144 00:06:07,900 --> 00:06:09,335 - She was an employee here, wasn't she? 145 00:06:09,402 --> 00:06:13,706 - Yeah, but she didn't have a bank account set up yet, 146 00:06:13,773 --> 00:06:17,844 so my dad was paying her cash under the table. 147 00:06:17,910 --> 00:06:19,545 - All right, you know anyone else 148 00:06:19,612 --> 00:06:22,014 that she was hanging out with, where she was living, 149 00:06:22,081 --> 00:06:23,349 how she spent her time off? 150 00:06:23,416 --> 00:06:25,752 - I don't think she knew many people in the city. 151 00:06:25,818 --> 00:06:28,721 She--she was staying at a youth hostel 152 00:06:28,788 --> 00:06:31,624 a few blocks from here, Millennial Lodge. 153 00:06:31,691 --> 00:06:34,160 - Chloe's one of our long-termers. 154 00:06:34,227 --> 00:06:36,929 Been here about six months. - Is that pretty common? 155 00:06:36,996 --> 00:06:38,765 - Not really, but it happens. 156 00:06:38,831 --> 00:06:41,567 Cheaper than paying New York rent, I guess. 157 00:06:41,634 --> 00:06:45,505 ♪ ♪ 158 00:06:45,571 --> 00:06:46,739 This is her. 159 00:06:46,806 --> 00:06:48,875 - Okay. Let's see here. 160 00:06:53,513 --> 00:06:55,081 Nothing here. 161 00:06:55,148 --> 00:06:56,582 - Did you know her at all? 162 00:06:56,649 --> 00:06:58,017 - Not really. 163 00:06:58,084 --> 00:07:02,088 I mean, she was nice but kinda kept to herself. 164 00:07:02,155 --> 00:07:04,323 We do these family dinners every Friday, 165 00:07:04,390 --> 00:07:05,892 go out afterwards. 166 00:07:05,958 --> 00:07:07,426 Chloe only came once. 167 00:07:07,493 --> 00:07:09,996 I don't think it was a great experience for her. 168 00:07:10,062 --> 00:07:11,230 - Yeah? Why is that? 169 00:07:11,297 --> 00:07:13,032 - Some guy got overly interested in her, 170 00:07:13,099 --> 00:07:14,600 followed her back here. 171 00:07:14,667 --> 00:07:17,236 And she's shy, you know. Didn't know how to handle it. 172 00:07:17,303 --> 00:07:19,806 The guys on staff had to chase him away. 173 00:07:19,872 --> 00:07:23,042 - When was this? - About a month ago. 174 00:07:23,109 --> 00:07:25,478 - You all have cameras outside? 175 00:07:25,545 --> 00:07:26,913 - This could be it. 176 00:07:26,979 --> 00:07:31,317 ♪ ♪ 177 00:07:31,384 --> 00:07:32,819 Can we--can we get sound on this? 178 00:07:32,885 --> 00:07:34,921 - Uh, no. It's video only. 179 00:07:38,925 --> 00:07:40,726 - He clearly has rage issues. 180 00:07:40,793 --> 00:07:42,562 Can we ID him from here? 181 00:07:42,628 --> 00:07:44,964 - Running facial rec now. 182 00:07:45,031 --> 00:07:46,566 Yep. Brett Porter. 183 00:07:46,632 --> 00:07:50,036 20 years old. He's a business major at NYU. 184 00:07:50,102 --> 00:07:52,772 - All right. Can we get a current location? 185 00:07:52,839 --> 00:07:54,340 - Can't guarantee he's there now, 186 00:07:54,407 --> 00:07:56,475 but it looks like he lives in off-campus student housing. 187 00:07:58,911 --> 00:08:02,048 [rap music playing] 188 00:08:02,114 --> 00:08:05,218 [indistinct chatter] 189 00:08:12,425 --> 00:08:13,793 - Hey! 190 00:08:15,494 --> 00:08:16,529 - FBI. 191 00:08:16,596 --> 00:08:17,864 We're not here to bust your party, 192 00:08:17,930 --> 00:08:19,899 but we need everyone to stay where they are. 193 00:08:19,966 --> 00:08:21,534 Where are you going? 194 00:08:21,601 --> 00:08:22,535 Sit down. 195 00:08:24,537 --> 00:08:26,172 - Hey. I live here. 196 00:08:26,239 --> 00:08:27,273 Everything okay? 197 00:08:27,340 --> 00:08:28,641 - We're looking for Brett Porter. 198 00:08:28,708 --> 00:08:30,243 You see him? 199 00:08:30,309 --> 00:08:33,212 - Yeah, uh, I think he went, um, into his room with a girl. 200 00:08:37,049 --> 00:08:39,952 [suspenseful music] 201 00:08:40,019 --> 00:08:41,921 ♪ ♪ 202 00:08:41,988 --> 00:08:43,222 - Hey, Brett, open up. 203 00:08:45,524 --> 00:08:46,459 - Open it. 204 00:08:52,064 --> 00:08:53,799 - Yo, what the hell? - Where's the girl? 205 00:08:53,866 --> 00:08:55,468 - In the bathroom. What's going on? 206 00:08:58,838 --> 00:09:00,673 - You okay? 207 00:09:00,740 --> 00:09:04,477 - Yeah, I--what's happening? 208 00:09:04,543 --> 00:09:06,979 - We have some questions to ask Brett about a missing girl. 209 00:09:07,046 --> 00:09:08,981 - Hold on. You can't just barge in here. 210 00:09:09,048 --> 00:09:10,182 - Actually, we can. 211 00:09:12,585 --> 00:09:14,120 - Look, I don't know what you want me to say. 212 00:09:14,186 --> 00:09:15,388 I don't know anyone named Chloe. 213 00:09:15,454 --> 00:09:17,757 - Well, it sure seems like you know her. 214 00:09:17,823 --> 00:09:18,925 - What is this? 215 00:09:18,991 --> 00:09:20,893 - You don't remember? 216 00:09:20,960 --> 00:09:21,994 You met her at the bar. 217 00:09:22,061 --> 00:09:23,996 You followed her to her hostel. 218 00:09:24,063 --> 00:09:26,299 This is you? Yeah? 219 00:09:26,365 --> 00:09:28,167 - Okay. 220 00:09:28,234 --> 00:09:29,435 Yeah. 221 00:09:29,502 --> 00:09:32,138 Look, I'll admit it wasn't my finest moment. 222 00:09:32,204 --> 00:09:34,073 But that's not Chloe, 223 00:09:34,140 --> 00:09:35,641 whatever you said her name was, that's Tasha. 224 00:09:35,708 --> 00:09:37,977 - Okay, whatever her name is, she was abducted last night. 225 00:09:38,044 --> 00:09:39,779 And we have you on video screaming at her 226 00:09:39,845 --> 00:09:41,280 a few weeks before she disappeared. 227 00:09:41,347 --> 00:09:42,848 So what happened? 228 00:09:42,915 --> 00:09:44,050 - She rejected you. 229 00:09:44,116 --> 00:09:46,052 You felt embarrassed. - No. Hold on. 230 00:09:46,118 --> 00:09:47,453 I--I wasn't into Tasha. 231 00:09:47,520 --> 00:09:48,988 - Chloe. 232 00:09:49,055 --> 00:09:50,690 - I'm telling you, that girl's name is Tasha. 233 00:09:50,756 --> 00:09:52,091 I know her from Poughkeepsie. 234 00:09:52,158 --> 00:09:53,292 - Okay, are you sure about that? 235 00:09:53,359 --> 00:09:55,928 - Yeah. She worked for my parents. 236 00:09:55,995 --> 00:09:57,096 Cleaned our house twice a week, 237 00:09:57,163 --> 00:10:00,299 until she robbed us and took off. 238 00:10:00,366 --> 00:10:01,734 - When was that? 239 00:10:01,801 --> 00:10:04,236 - Last summer. Maybe July? 240 00:10:04,303 --> 00:10:06,539 So when I ran into her, I confronted her about it. 241 00:10:06,605 --> 00:10:07,940 But that's it. 242 00:10:08,007 --> 00:10:09,442 That's the last time I saw her. 243 00:10:09,508 --> 00:10:14,747 ♪ ♪ 244 00:10:14,814 --> 00:10:16,282 - Brett Porter alibied out. 245 00:10:16,349 --> 00:10:17,984 He was at a university fundraiser. 246 00:10:18,050 --> 00:10:19,418 We've got about a dozen photos confirming it. 247 00:10:19,485 --> 00:10:21,153 - At least that's something definitive. 248 00:10:21,220 --> 00:10:23,289 - So still no firm ID on our victim? 249 00:10:23,356 --> 00:10:24,724 - No, and the deeper we dig into her, 250 00:10:24,790 --> 00:10:26,092 the more questions we have. 251 00:10:26,158 --> 00:10:27,426 You get her toothbrush to the lab? 252 00:10:27,493 --> 00:10:29,395 - Yeah, they're running her DNA now. 253 00:10:29,462 --> 00:10:30,663 - Okay. I know it's a long shot, 254 00:10:30,730 --> 00:10:32,431 but we know she has a history of theft. 255 00:10:32,498 --> 00:10:34,100 Maybe she's in the criminal database. 256 00:10:34,166 --> 00:10:35,434 Hey, you talk to Brett's parents? 257 00:10:35,501 --> 00:10:37,136 - Yeah, they confirmed Chloe worked for them 258 00:10:37,203 --> 00:10:38,437 under the name Tasha, 259 00:10:38,504 --> 00:10:40,106 and that she stole $2,000 from them. 260 00:10:40,172 --> 00:10:41,440 But they didn't have much info on her. 261 00:10:41,507 --> 00:10:43,042 Same situation as the pizza place-- 262 00:10:43,109 --> 00:10:44,443 paid her under the table, didn't even know 263 00:10:44,510 --> 00:10:45,978 her last name. - Great. All right. 264 00:10:46,045 --> 00:10:47,747 Folks, we should all be working on this. 265 00:10:47,813 --> 00:10:49,882 This woman did not just appear out of nowhere. 266 00:10:49,949 --> 00:10:51,250 Let's keep searching social media. 267 00:10:51,317 --> 00:10:53,052 And hey, Phil, why don't you get a team together. 268 00:10:53,119 --> 00:10:55,287 Start cold-calling Poughkeepsie, yeah? 269 00:10:55,354 --> 00:10:57,423 - Hey, Jubal. That was the lab. 270 00:10:57,490 --> 00:10:59,692 We just got a hit on her DNA. - So she has a record. 271 00:10:59,759 --> 00:11:01,627 - Not exactly. 272 00:11:01,694 --> 00:11:03,763 She popped in NamUs. 273 00:11:03,829 --> 00:11:05,164 - The missing persons database? 274 00:11:05,231 --> 00:11:08,267 - Real name Annabelle Collier. 275 00:11:08,334 --> 00:11:11,203 She was abducted from Staten Island at age four, 276 00:11:11,270 --> 00:11:13,105 and presumed dead for the past 18 years. 277 00:11:13,172 --> 00:11:20,312 ♪ ♪ 278 00:11:29,588 --> 00:11:30,956 - Annabelle Collier was abducted outside 279 00:11:31,023 --> 00:11:33,292 of a daycare center back in 2004. 280 00:11:33,359 --> 00:11:34,427 Her mom's a waitress. 281 00:11:34,493 --> 00:11:35,995 Still lives out in Staten Island. 282 00:11:36,062 --> 00:11:38,230 Her father was a contractor, but he died of a heart attack. 283 00:11:38,297 --> 00:11:39,532 - In 2008. 284 00:11:39,598 --> 00:11:41,100 - That's--that's right. How do you-- 285 00:11:41,167 --> 00:11:43,469 - The Collier abduction was one of my first cases 286 00:11:43,536 --> 00:11:45,271 when I joined the bureau. 287 00:11:45,337 --> 00:11:47,706 I kept in contact with her parents for years 288 00:11:47,773 --> 00:11:49,675 after we closed the case. 289 00:11:49,742 --> 00:11:51,644 Jubal, we got the guy who took Annabelle. 290 00:11:51,710 --> 00:11:52,778 He confessed to killing her. 291 00:11:52,845 --> 00:11:54,814 - I--I know. I read the report. 292 00:11:54,880 --> 00:11:56,949 But the DNA is conclusive. 293 00:11:57,016 --> 00:11:59,485 Chloe Rogers and Annabelle Collier are the same person. 294 00:11:59,552 --> 00:12:02,054 [suspenseful music] 295 00:12:02,121 --> 00:12:04,623 You know, we're kind of hitting a wall on this one. 296 00:12:04,690 --> 00:12:06,959 I was hoping you could provide some context. 297 00:12:07,026 --> 00:12:08,394 I guess you and your old partner 298 00:12:08,461 --> 00:12:11,764 know more about the Collier case than anyone else. 299 00:12:11,831 --> 00:12:15,101 Maybe you could--are--are you still in touch with him? 300 00:12:15,167 --> 00:12:17,103 - No. No, not for years. 301 00:12:17,169 --> 00:12:19,004 But he still works with the FBI, 302 00:12:19,071 --> 00:12:21,140 with Crimes Against Children in New Haven. 303 00:12:21,207 --> 00:12:22,808 - I can give him a call. 304 00:12:22,875 --> 00:12:24,176 - No, I'll reach out. 305 00:12:24,243 --> 00:12:26,145 It was our case. He should hear it from me. 306 00:12:26,212 --> 00:12:31,550 ♪ ♪ 307 00:12:31,617 --> 00:12:33,652 [indistinct chatter] 308 00:12:33,719 --> 00:12:35,354 - Hey, stranger. 309 00:12:35,421 --> 00:12:36,722 - Hey. 310 00:12:36,789 --> 00:12:38,524 Thank you for coming all the way down here. 311 00:12:38,591 --> 00:12:39,959 - It's perfect timing. 312 00:12:40,025 --> 00:12:42,394 It's Angie's week for the kids, and I was in the city 313 00:12:42,461 --> 00:12:43,529 dropping them off anyway. 314 00:12:43,596 --> 00:12:45,564 Cream, no sugar. 315 00:12:45,631 --> 00:12:46,799 - Thank you. 316 00:12:46,866 --> 00:12:48,534 I actually drink it black now. 317 00:12:48,601 --> 00:12:51,170 Turns out all that cream is not as healthy as we once thought. 318 00:12:51,237 --> 00:12:52,905 - Don't tell me you've turned into a health nut. 319 00:12:52,972 --> 00:12:55,774 - [chuckles] No. - That's no fun. 320 00:12:55,841 --> 00:12:57,176 So what's going on? 321 00:12:57,243 --> 00:13:00,346 You said you got a DNA hit on Annabelle Collier? 322 00:13:00,412 --> 00:13:03,249 - Yeah, on an abduction case that we're working. 323 00:13:03,315 --> 00:13:06,352 DNA is a 100% match. 324 00:13:06,418 --> 00:13:07,953 - You sure? - Positive. 325 00:13:08,020 --> 00:13:10,956 Annabelle's alive, 22 years old. 326 00:13:11,023 --> 00:13:13,192 She's been out there the whole time. 327 00:13:13,259 --> 00:13:16,428 I--I don't understand how this could be possible. 328 00:13:16,495 --> 00:13:18,564 I mean, Eddie Lyman confessed to killing her. 329 00:13:18,631 --> 00:13:20,366 - I guess he was lying. 330 00:13:20,432 --> 00:13:22,635 But that doesn't mean he wasn't our abductor. 331 00:13:22,701 --> 00:13:24,103 - Really? 332 00:13:24,170 --> 00:13:25,838 Because he's been in prison for the past 17 years. 333 00:13:25,905 --> 00:13:27,973 - He could have handed her off to an accomplice 334 00:13:28,040 --> 00:13:31,210 or sold her to some sex trafficker. 335 00:13:31,277 --> 00:13:33,345 - Whatever happened, we missed it. 336 00:13:33,412 --> 00:13:35,915 And we stopped looking for that little girl. 337 00:13:35,981 --> 00:13:38,851 - We worked off the intel we had at the time. 338 00:13:40,586 --> 00:13:43,856 The important thing is to focus on the present, okay? 339 00:13:43,923 --> 00:13:46,492 Good news is, 340 00:13:46,559 --> 00:13:48,294 we got another shot at this. 341 00:13:48,360 --> 00:13:49,495 - [sighs] Yeah. 342 00:13:49,562 --> 00:13:51,964 The problem is, we don't have any leads. 343 00:13:52,031 --> 00:13:54,366 - Well, we may have one. 344 00:13:54,433 --> 00:13:57,836 Apparently Eddie Lyman beat his case on appeal. 345 00:13:57,903 --> 00:13:59,838 He's been out of prison for four months. 346 00:13:59,905 --> 00:14:05,110 ♪ ♪ 347 00:14:05,177 --> 00:14:06,378 - Eddie Lyman. 348 00:14:06,445 --> 00:14:08,280 He went to prison back in 2004 349 00:14:08,347 --> 00:14:11,383 for the abduction and murder of Annabelle Collier. 350 00:14:11,450 --> 00:14:13,319 Annabelle was a four-year-old little girl 351 00:14:13,385 --> 00:14:16,322 who was taken from a playground at her daycare center 352 00:14:16,388 --> 00:14:18,924 outside of Staten Island. - Lyman was her neighbor. 353 00:14:18,991 --> 00:14:21,360 He was in his 20s at the time and a known predator. 354 00:14:21,427 --> 00:14:24,096 - And according to this, even before Annabelle went missing, 355 00:14:24,163 --> 00:14:26,498 Lyman served time for child pornography, 356 00:14:26,565 --> 00:14:27,967 molestation, luring of a minor. 357 00:14:28,033 --> 00:14:29,435 - Right. 358 00:14:29,501 --> 00:14:31,670 Annabelle's mother had reported him for being creepy. 359 00:14:31,737 --> 00:14:34,006 You know, loitering, leering, 360 00:14:34,073 --> 00:14:35,841 trying to start conversations with young girls. 361 00:14:35,908 --> 00:14:37,243 - Checked his phone. 362 00:14:37,309 --> 00:14:38,677 Cell records showed him near the daycare 363 00:14:38,744 --> 00:14:41,080 at the time of the abduction. 364 00:14:41,146 --> 00:14:43,182 Even without his confession, 365 00:14:43,249 --> 00:14:45,017 the case against him was solid. 366 00:14:45,084 --> 00:14:46,852 - So how did he end up back on the street? 367 00:14:46,919 --> 00:14:48,254 - The public defender who represented him 368 00:14:48,320 --> 00:14:50,756 was an alcoholic, disbarred a few years back. 369 00:14:50,823 --> 00:14:52,424 - Ineffective assistance of counsel. 370 00:14:52,491 --> 00:14:54,927 Lyman was released, pending a new trial. 371 00:14:54,994 --> 00:14:57,963 - Just in time for Annabelle to disappear again. 372 00:14:58,030 --> 00:14:59,732 - I just got off the phone with Lyman's parole officer. 373 00:14:59,798 --> 00:15:01,300 He's working as a janitor at a place 374 00:15:01,367 --> 00:15:02,534 called the Cameron Motel. 375 00:15:02,601 --> 00:15:04,403 - Okay. Lyman could be our guy, folks. 376 00:15:04,470 --> 00:15:05,738 Let's get a full team down there, 377 00:15:05,804 --> 00:15:06,772 ready to search that motel. 378 00:15:06,839 --> 00:15:08,374 - Copy that. 379 00:15:08,440 --> 00:15:12,444 ♪ ♪ 380 00:15:12,511 --> 00:15:14,213 - Lyman has access to dozens of motel rooms, 381 00:15:14,280 --> 00:15:15,814 and Annabelle could be in any one of them, 382 00:15:15,881 --> 00:15:17,182 so it's imperative that we contain him 383 00:15:17,249 --> 00:15:18,684 before he knows we're onsite. Understood? 384 00:15:18,751 --> 00:15:19,952 agents: Yes, ma'am. 385 00:15:20,019 --> 00:15:21,854 - Jubal, how are we looking on your end? 386 00:15:21,920 --> 00:15:23,756 - Yeah, Elise is going through motel records, 387 00:15:23,822 --> 00:15:25,057 making a list of vacant rooms. 388 00:15:25,124 --> 00:15:26,759 Should have that to Scola in the next five. 389 00:15:26,825 --> 00:15:28,127 - Copy that. - All right. 390 00:15:28,193 --> 00:15:29,328 - We'll let you know when we have eyes on Lyman. 391 00:15:29,395 --> 00:15:32,331 [tense music] 392 00:15:32,398 --> 00:15:39,338 ♪ ♪ 393 00:16:09,535 --> 00:16:10,836 - Hey, look. 394 00:16:26,618 --> 00:16:27,553 Go. 395 00:16:54,246 --> 00:16:56,248 - Eddie Lyman, FBI. Drop it. Hands up. 396 00:16:56,315 --> 00:16:57,483 - Hey. Hey. Just take it easy. 397 00:16:57,549 --> 00:16:58,751 Take it easy. 398 00:16:58,817 --> 00:16:59,918 - What are you doing with that bleach? 399 00:16:59,985 --> 00:17:01,487 - A kid threw up in one of the bathrooms. 400 00:17:01,553 --> 00:17:03,422 - Where's Annabelle? - Annabelle? 401 00:17:03,489 --> 00:17:05,124 - The girl you abducted 18 years ago. 402 00:17:05,190 --> 00:17:06,592 - Oh, you gotta be kidding me. 403 00:17:06,657 --> 00:17:07,726 I never touched that girl. 404 00:17:07,792 --> 00:17:09,560 - Get him out of here. 405 00:17:09,627 --> 00:17:11,730 - Wha--come on, man. 406 00:17:11,797 --> 00:17:13,598 You cannot be serious right now. 407 00:17:13,665 --> 00:17:15,567 - Tiff, we got him. Move in. 408 00:17:15,634 --> 00:17:17,069 - [sighs] God. 409 00:17:17,136 --> 00:17:24,175 ♪ ♪ 410 00:17:24,242 --> 00:17:26,377 - You got that one. You guys, come with me. 411 00:17:31,650 --> 00:17:34,453 - I don't know how many times I have to say it. 412 00:17:34,520 --> 00:17:35,788 I didn't take that girl. 413 00:17:35,854 --> 00:17:37,322 Not yesterday. 414 00:17:37,389 --> 00:17:38,824 Not 18 years ago. 415 00:17:38,891 --> 00:17:40,325 - That's not what you said back then. 416 00:17:40,392 --> 00:17:42,327 - Yeah, well, I was confused. 417 00:17:42,394 --> 00:17:44,263 He got me all mixed up. - No. 418 00:17:44,329 --> 00:17:46,432 You were released because your lawyer was a drunk. 419 00:17:46,498 --> 00:17:48,434 - Yeah, who told me I get to go home 420 00:17:48,500 --> 00:17:50,335 if I said what you wanted me to. 421 00:17:50,402 --> 00:17:51,570 I was blindsided. 422 00:17:51,637 --> 00:17:53,672 - We are not here to re-try your case. 423 00:17:53,739 --> 00:17:55,974 You're gonna get another shot at that in a few months. 424 00:17:56,041 --> 00:17:57,943 But what do you think the jury's gonna say 425 00:17:58,010 --> 00:18:00,913 when they find out you didn't last a year on the outside 426 00:18:00,979 --> 00:18:03,449 without attacking this poor girl again? 427 00:18:04,817 --> 00:18:06,752 - Why are you doing this? 428 00:18:06,819 --> 00:18:08,554 I don't know this girl. 429 00:18:08,620 --> 00:18:12,524 - We have you on camera with her last night. 430 00:18:12,591 --> 00:18:14,726 - No. That isn't me. 431 00:18:14,793 --> 00:18:15,961 - Really? 432 00:18:16,028 --> 00:18:17,563 Because that looks a hell of a lot like 433 00:18:17,629 --> 00:18:19,531 the ring you were wearing when we picked you up. 434 00:18:19,598 --> 00:18:20,966 Silver band, red stone. 435 00:18:21,033 --> 00:18:22,601 - Okay. Yeah. 436 00:18:22,668 --> 00:18:24,203 It looks like the same ring. 437 00:18:24,269 --> 00:18:27,773 But I ain't the only guy who has one. 438 00:18:27,840 --> 00:18:29,341 It's a class ring. 439 00:18:29,408 --> 00:18:31,610 Half of Oakwood High has that same ring. 440 00:18:31,677 --> 00:18:33,645 Guys--guys who lived in the same neighborhood 441 00:18:33,712 --> 00:18:36,114 as me 18 years ago. 442 00:18:36,181 --> 00:18:37,549 That isn't me. 443 00:18:39,284 --> 00:18:41,954 You got the wrong guy. 444 00:18:42,020 --> 00:18:43,522 Again. 445 00:18:51,730 --> 00:18:54,032 - I wanna go home too, okay? But that's not how it works. 446 00:18:54,099 --> 00:18:56,301 All right, you're not gonna go home until you tell me 447 00:18:56,368 --> 00:18:57,936 what you did with the little girl. 448 00:18:58,003 --> 00:19:00,072 - I already told you. 449 00:19:00,138 --> 00:19:03,675 - You've told me, like, six different stories, Eddie. 450 00:19:03,742 --> 00:19:05,244 What's going on? Come on. 451 00:19:05,310 --> 00:19:07,145 I need the truth. [knock at door] 452 00:19:07,212 --> 00:19:08,680 All right. One more time. Let's take it back. 453 00:19:08,747 --> 00:19:10,315 October 5th. - Hey. 454 00:19:10,382 --> 00:19:11,550 - Hey. 455 00:19:11,617 --> 00:19:13,852 - So Lyman's alibi checks out. 456 00:19:13,919 --> 00:19:17,155 He was at work at the time of the abduction. 457 00:19:17,222 --> 00:19:18,423 - Okay. 458 00:19:18,490 --> 00:19:20,626 Thank you. 459 00:19:20,692 --> 00:19:22,594 - What you watching? 460 00:19:22,661 --> 00:19:25,297 - It's Lyman's original confession. 461 00:19:27,733 --> 00:19:28,800 - From there. 462 00:19:28,867 --> 00:19:30,269 - I went to go see the kids. 463 00:19:30,335 --> 00:19:32,237 They were on the playground, and-- 464 00:19:32,304 --> 00:19:34,172 - You went to go see Annabelle? 465 00:19:34,239 --> 00:19:35,374 - Yeah. 466 00:19:35,440 --> 00:19:36,642 I saw Annabelle. 467 00:19:36,708 --> 00:19:38,410 - Okay. 468 00:19:38,477 --> 00:19:40,979 Now we're getting somewhere. 469 00:19:41,046 --> 00:19:43,215 - I was at a Quantico in-service 470 00:19:43,282 --> 00:19:44,983 when Lyman was arrested, 471 00:19:45,050 --> 00:19:46,652 and Jake took the confession alone. 472 00:19:46,718 --> 00:19:48,854 - Okay. And? 473 00:19:48,921 --> 00:19:51,056 - You can see Ly-- Lyman is unstable. 474 00:19:51,123 --> 00:19:52,491 And Jake is pushing him really hard, 475 00:19:52,558 --> 00:19:54,059 spinning him upside down. 476 00:19:54,126 --> 00:19:56,161 - Well, you had other evidence on Lyman, right? 477 00:19:56,228 --> 00:19:58,030 What, the--the cell data. 478 00:19:58,096 --> 00:20:00,599 - Yeah. I had Ian look into it. 479 00:20:00,666 --> 00:20:03,135 It turns out technology has come a long way since then. 480 00:20:03,201 --> 00:20:05,871 The carrier overestimated their ability 481 00:20:05,938 --> 00:20:08,173 to pinpoint the location data. 482 00:20:08,240 --> 00:20:09,374 - Meaning? 483 00:20:09,441 --> 00:20:11,777 - Meaning Lyman could have been anywhere 484 00:20:11,843 --> 00:20:14,012 within a five-mile radius of that daycare. 485 00:20:14,079 --> 00:20:18,283 Including at home, where he said he was. 486 00:20:18,350 --> 00:20:20,018 - Right. 487 00:20:20,085 --> 00:20:23,789 - Jubal, I buried the wrong guy. 488 00:20:23,855 --> 00:20:26,992 And as a result, we stopped looking for Annabelle. 489 00:20:27,059 --> 00:20:31,396 [apprehensive music] 490 00:20:31,463 --> 00:20:34,399 [phone buzzes] 491 00:20:34,466 --> 00:20:37,002 - Good news is, we have better information now. 492 00:20:37,069 --> 00:20:40,272 JOC just got a lead on the ring our abductor was wearing. 493 00:20:40,339 --> 00:20:41,273 - Okay. 494 00:20:46,044 --> 00:20:47,379 - The class ring that our present-day abductor 495 00:20:47,446 --> 00:20:48,880 was wearing comes from the same high school 496 00:20:48,947 --> 00:20:50,349 Lyman attended--Oakwood. 497 00:20:50,415 --> 00:20:51,950 - Which means that the person we're looking for 498 00:20:52,017 --> 00:20:53,385 is from the same town where Annabelle Collier 499 00:20:53,452 --> 00:20:54,686 was abducted back in 2004, 500 00:20:54,753 --> 00:20:56,989 which is either a crazy coincidence, or-- 501 00:20:57,055 --> 00:20:59,391 - Or we're looking for the same abductor. 502 00:20:59,458 --> 00:21:01,593 - Is there any way to track who bought those rings? 503 00:21:01,660 --> 00:21:02,928 - Yes, we called the company, 504 00:21:02,995 --> 00:21:04,863 and Elise has the original purchase order. 505 00:21:04,930 --> 00:21:06,932 - There were 36 men in that graduating class 506 00:21:06,999 --> 00:21:08,667 who ordered rings, but eliminating anyone 507 00:21:08,734 --> 00:21:10,068 who's passed away or doesn't match 508 00:21:10,135 --> 00:21:11,503 our abductor's physical description, 509 00:21:11,570 --> 00:21:12,704 and we're left with six men. 510 00:21:12,771 --> 00:21:14,840 - Right. Okay. 511 00:21:14,906 --> 00:21:16,742 Yeah, yeah, yeah. 512 00:21:16,808 --> 00:21:18,677 Um, we can bring them in for questioning? 513 00:21:18,744 --> 00:21:19,911 - I'd hold off-- that part of Staten Island 514 00:21:19,978 --> 00:21:21,146 operates like a small town. 515 00:21:21,213 --> 00:21:23,548 We go in there without concrete intel, 516 00:21:23,615 --> 00:21:25,250 we risk spooking our perp. - Right. 517 00:21:25,317 --> 00:21:26,618 All right, let me see what I can do 518 00:21:26,685 --> 00:21:28,253 to narrow it down from here. - Okay. 519 00:21:28,320 --> 00:21:30,055 You know, there is one person from that neighborhood 520 00:21:30,122 --> 00:21:32,090 I think we're safe talking to. 521 00:21:32,157 --> 00:21:33,859 - You wanna go to the girl's mom? 522 00:21:33,925 --> 00:21:35,560 - If we are looking for the same guy, 523 00:21:35,627 --> 00:21:37,629 maybe Joan Collier knew him. 524 00:21:37,696 --> 00:21:40,599 [suspenseful music] 525 00:21:40,666 --> 00:21:47,773 ♪ ♪ 526 00:21:48,807 --> 00:21:50,142 - You sure it's her? 527 00:21:50,208 --> 00:21:51,543 - We're positive. 528 00:21:51,610 --> 00:21:53,245 Annabelle's alive. 529 00:21:55,814 --> 00:21:57,149 - Oh, my God. 530 00:21:59,217 --> 00:22:00,886 But I don't-- I don't understand. 531 00:22:00,952 --> 00:22:03,188 You told me-- 532 00:22:03,255 --> 00:22:04,823 you told me Eddie Lyman confessed. 533 00:22:04,890 --> 00:22:06,925 You said he killed her. 534 00:22:06,992 --> 00:22:09,461 - That's what he told us at the time. 535 00:22:09,528 --> 00:22:11,163 - And you just-- 536 00:22:11,229 --> 00:22:13,532 you just took his word for it? 537 00:22:13,598 --> 00:22:14,900 - Well, not exactly. 538 00:22:14,966 --> 00:22:17,335 - My daughter's been out there for years, 539 00:22:17,402 --> 00:22:19,037 going through God knows what, because what? 540 00:22:19,104 --> 00:22:21,707 You--you wanted another win on your record? 541 00:22:21,773 --> 00:22:23,842 You wanted to move on? You wanted to make it easier? 542 00:22:23,909 --> 00:22:25,377 - I know you're upset. 543 00:22:25,444 --> 00:22:26,445 I get it. 544 00:22:26,511 --> 00:22:28,113 - You get it? 545 00:22:28,180 --> 00:22:29,881 You get what it's like thinking your daughter 546 00:22:29,948 --> 00:22:31,316 is dead when she's not? 547 00:22:33,318 --> 00:22:35,153 - I'm sorry. I didn't--I didn't-- 548 00:22:35,220 --> 00:22:37,055 I didn't mean it literally. 549 00:22:37,122 --> 00:22:40,092 But we didn't just take his word for it. 550 00:22:40,158 --> 00:22:43,829 We closed the case on the totality of the evidence. 551 00:22:43,895 --> 00:22:46,498 And frankly, revisiting the past 552 00:22:46,565 --> 00:22:49,167 isn't gonna help us find your daughter now. 553 00:22:52,971 --> 00:22:55,974 Look, this is-- this is good news. 554 00:22:56,041 --> 00:22:57,809 Your daughter is alive. 555 00:22:57,876 --> 00:23:00,679 - You just told me she was abducted. 556 00:23:00,746 --> 00:23:02,781 Again. How is that good news? 557 00:23:02,848 --> 00:23:05,484 - Because she's breathing. 558 00:23:05,550 --> 00:23:08,286 Alive is better than dead. 559 00:23:08,353 --> 00:23:09,955 It just is. 560 00:23:10,021 --> 00:23:11,256 - This is-- this is unbelievable. 561 00:23:11,323 --> 00:23:14,025 You people act like I don't have feelings. 562 00:23:14,092 --> 00:23:16,394 That little girl was my daughter, 563 00:23:16,461 --> 00:23:19,431 and you told me she was dead, and she's not. 564 00:23:19,498 --> 00:23:20,799 - Joan. 565 00:23:22,367 --> 00:23:24,236 Listen to me. 566 00:23:24,302 --> 00:23:28,173 You have every right to be upset, to hate us. 567 00:23:29,908 --> 00:23:33,745 But right now, we need your help to find your daughter. 568 00:23:33,812 --> 00:23:35,447 Annabelle. 569 00:23:35,514 --> 00:23:42,420 ♪ ♪ 570 00:23:44,089 --> 00:23:46,258 Just me and you, okay? 571 00:23:59,437 --> 00:24:05,610 Now, my team has narrowed it down to six suspects. 572 00:24:08,313 --> 00:24:11,283 They're all from the same area. 573 00:24:11,349 --> 00:24:14,920 They went to the same high school. 574 00:24:17,756 --> 00:24:24,429 Just let me know if you recognize any of them. 575 00:24:24,496 --> 00:24:31,436 ♪ ♪ 576 00:24:35,440 --> 00:24:37,008 - That's him. 577 00:24:37,075 --> 00:24:38,443 - Jeff Whalen? - Yeah. 578 00:24:38,510 --> 00:24:42,948 He, uh--he worked for my husband. 579 00:24:43,014 --> 00:24:46,585 He was...kind of a sad kid. 580 00:24:46,651 --> 00:24:48,453 He lost his parents young. 581 00:24:49,855 --> 00:24:51,256 A bit of a loner. 582 00:24:51,323 --> 00:24:53,959 - Was he ever around Annabelle? 583 00:24:54,025 --> 00:24:55,660 - Yeah, he was, uh-- 584 00:24:57,329 --> 00:25:00,498 He was kind of attentive to her. 585 00:25:00,565 --> 00:25:04,069 Yeah, and I-- I thought it was sweet, 586 00:25:04,135 --> 00:25:05,237 because he didn't have a family. 587 00:25:05,303 --> 00:25:09,040 But then he-- he stopped coming around 588 00:25:09,107 --> 00:25:10,508 when Annabelle went missing. 589 00:25:10,575 --> 00:25:12,811 Oh, my God. Oh, my God. 590 00:25:12,878 --> 00:25:14,446 [sobs] 591 00:25:14,512 --> 00:25:16,114 - Joan. 592 00:25:16,181 --> 00:25:18,216 Hey. It's gonna be okay. 593 00:25:22,888 --> 00:25:24,022 - Yeah? 594 00:25:25,257 --> 00:25:27,025 That's what you said last time. 595 00:25:27,092 --> 00:25:34,032 ♪ ♪ 596 00:25:34,099 --> 00:25:35,400 - Anything? 597 00:25:35,467 --> 00:25:36,601 - Yeah. 598 00:25:36,668 --> 00:25:37,802 She ID'd one of them. 599 00:25:37,869 --> 00:25:39,471 Jeff Whalen. 600 00:25:39,537 --> 00:25:40,972 - Good. 601 00:25:41,039 --> 00:25:42,674 Glad you were able to connect with her. 602 00:25:42,741 --> 00:25:45,110 - Yeah, it's funny how much easier that is 603 00:25:45,176 --> 00:25:47,112 when you're not trying to gaslight her. 604 00:25:47,178 --> 00:25:49,014 - Izzy, she was spinning out. 605 00:25:49,080 --> 00:25:50,882 We're working an abduction case. 606 00:25:50,949 --> 00:25:52,484 Every minute counts. 607 00:25:52,550 --> 00:25:55,921 We don't have time to hold her hand and beg for forgiveness. 608 00:25:55,987 --> 00:25:57,522 - You don't think we owe her that? 609 00:25:57,589 --> 00:25:59,591 After what that woman has been through? 610 00:25:59,658 --> 00:26:03,328 - Like I keep saying, we worked off the intel that we had. 611 00:26:03,395 --> 00:26:04,663 - So? 612 00:26:04,729 --> 00:26:07,098 How does that help Joan Collier or her daughter? 613 00:26:07,165 --> 00:26:09,534 - Look, I feel the same way you do. 614 00:26:09,601 --> 00:26:12,103 But we did the best that we could. 615 00:26:13,538 --> 00:26:14,472 - Did we? 616 00:26:16,041 --> 00:26:17,142 - What the hell does that mean? 617 00:26:17,208 --> 00:26:19,110 [tense music] 618 00:26:19,177 --> 00:26:22,147 - It means we had a lot going on back then. 619 00:26:24,015 --> 00:26:27,018 - That had nothing to do with any of this. 620 00:26:30,155 --> 00:26:32,891 - Seems to me we were either fighting, or-- 621 00:26:32,958 --> 00:26:34,559 - No. 622 00:26:34,626 --> 00:26:35,827 If anything, us being together helped us 623 00:26:35,894 --> 00:26:38,129 deal with the stress and the late nights. 624 00:26:38,196 --> 00:26:42,867 Izzy, we were good together. We were. 625 00:26:42,934 --> 00:26:45,437 We followed the leads that we had, and they didn't work out. 626 00:26:45,503 --> 00:26:47,772 That's just what happens sometimes. 627 00:26:47,839 --> 00:26:49,541 Hell, this guy Whalen, 628 00:26:49,607 --> 00:26:52,010 he wasn't even on our radar back then. 629 00:26:52,077 --> 00:26:57,182 So do yourself a favor and let it go. 630 00:26:57,248 --> 00:26:58,650 - Let it go? 631 00:26:58,717 --> 00:27:00,018 - Only thing you can do. 632 00:27:00,085 --> 00:27:01,453 - No. 633 00:27:01,519 --> 00:27:04,656 The only thing we can do is find Annabelle. 634 00:27:07,258 --> 00:27:10,195 This time, anyway. 635 00:27:10,261 --> 00:27:14,432 ♪ ♪ 636 00:27:14,499 --> 00:27:15,600 - All right, I wanna know everything 637 00:27:15,667 --> 00:27:17,068 there is to know about Jeff Whalen. 638 00:27:17,135 --> 00:27:18,536 Who he is, what he's been doing, 639 00:27:18,603 --> 00:27:20,605 who his childhood best friends are. 640 00:27:20,672 --> 00:27:23,074 - Whalen was born in Poughkeepsie in 1980. 641 00:27:23,141 --> 00:27:24,442 Only child. 642 00:27:24,509 --> 00:27:26,011 His parents moved him to Staten Island 643 00:27:26,077 --> 00:27:27,379 when he was in junior high, 644 00:27:27,445 --> 00:27:29,347 but they were both killed in a car accident 645 00:27:29,414 --> 00:27:30,615 a couple of years later. 646 00:27:30,682 --> 00:27:32,283 Whalen bounced around foster homes 647 00:27:32,350 --> 00:27:34,519 for the rest of high school until he turned 18. 648 00:27:34,586 --> 00:27:36,788 - From there, he started working odd jobs 649 00:27:36,855 --> 00:27:40,392 as a carpenter on Staten Island up until early 2004. 650 00:27:40,458 --> 00:27:43,061 He pretty much falls off the grid after that. 651 00:27:43,128 --> 00:27:44,829 - What do you mean? What--where'd he go? 652 00:27:44,896 --> 00:27:46,364 - No clue. 653 00:27:46,431 --> 00:27:48,433 Last employment on file was terminated four months 654 00:27:48,500 --> 00:27:49,734 before Annabelle disappeared. 655 00:27:49,801 --> 00:27:51,336 After that, he's a ghost. 656 00:27:51,403 --> 00:27:53,671 - Well, he's supposedly been living out in the world, right? 657 00:27:53,738 --> 00:27:56,107 - Well, not under that name or Social Security number. 658 00:27:56,174 --> 00:27:57,542 - You said he was from Poughkeepsie, right? 659 00:27:57,609 --> 00:27:58,977 - Mm-hmm. 660 00:27:59,044 --> 00:28:00,779 - Well, our victim was living up there with her dad 661 00:28:00,845 --> 00:28:02,247 under a fake name. 662 00:28:02,313 --> 00:28:03,381 Maybe Whalen's using a fake name too. 663 00:28:03,448 --> 00:28:04,682 - That's a good idea. 664 00:28:04,749 --> 00:28:07,385 Let's run his photo through the DMV database. 665 00:28:07,452 --> 00:28:09,821 - Okay, I got something. Jim Wilson, 42 years old. 666 00:28:09,888 --> 00:28:12,223 Lives in Fairview, 15 minutes outside of Poughkeepsie. 667 00:28:12,290 --> 00:28:14,092 - Yeah, yeah, yeah! That's him. 668 00:28:14,159 --> 00:28:15,860 Is this address current? - I think so. 669 00:28:15,927 --> 00:28:18,096 Property records still list him as the owner, 670 00:28:18,163 --> 00:28:20,031 and he's still paying utilities. 671 00:28:20,098 --> 00:28:21,199 - All right, let's check it out. 672 00:28:21,266 --> 00:28:28,406 ♪ ♪ 673 00:28:32,343 --> 00:28:34,212 - Heads up. 674 00:28:34,279 --> 00:28:36,815 Gray Honda Civic pulling in now. 675 00:28:44,122 --> 00:28:45,256 - Is that him? 676 00:28:45,323 --> 00:28:47,292 - Hard to tell from here. 677 00:28:49,360 --> 00:28:51,796 He's headed in the house. 678 00:28:55,400 --> 00:28:57,302 - Jeff Whalen! FBI. 679 00:28:57,368 --> 00:28:58,903 We need to talk. - Set the bag down. 680 00:28:58,970 --> 00:29:01,039 Turn around. Now. 681 00:29:01,106 --> 00:29:02,841 - Okay. Okay. 682 00:29:02,907 --> 00:29:04,375 I'm putting the bag down. 683 00:29:08,079 --> 00:29:10,115 - Who are you? - Paul Carson. 684 00:29:10,181 --> 00:29:12,183 What do you guys want? 685 00:29:12,250 --> 00:29:13,351 - You live here? 686 00:29:13,418 --> 00:29:15,820 - Yeah, I moved in this fall. 687 00:29:15,887 --> 00:29:18,089 - Where's the guy who owns this house? 688 00:29:18,156 --> 00:29:19,524 - I don't know. 689 00:29:19,591 --> 00:29:20,959 He left town right around the time I moved in. 690 00:29:21,025 --> 00:29:25,663 ♪ ♪ 691 00:29:32,036 --> 00:29:34,339 - Yeah. I knew him as Jim Wilson. 692 00:29:34,405 --> 00:29:35,907 He's lived in town as long as I've been around. 693 00:29:35,974 --> 00:29:38,276 At least 15 years. 694 00:29:38,343 --> 00:29:39,544 - He live alone? 695 00:29:39,611 --> 00:29:41,312 - No, he's got a daughter. 696 00:29:41,379 --> 00:29:43,481 Probably college age now. 697 00:29:43,548 --> 00:29:44,649 - That her? 698 00:29:44,716 --> 00:29:46,918 - Yeah, Tasha. Nice girl. 699 00:29:46,985 --> 00:29:49,854 A little quiet, but they both were. 700 00:29:49,921 --> 00:29:51,589 - What was their relationship like? 701 00:29:51,656 --> 00:29:54,425 Tasha and her father, based off what you saw? 702 00:29:54,492 --> 00:29:59,797 - They were a little strange, to be honest with you. 703 00:29:59,864 --> 00:30:01,933 Very insular. 704 00:30:02,000 --> 00:30:04,369 Got the feeling he was kind of overprotective, 705 00:30:04,435 --> 00:30:08,072 but I guess she broke out on her own eventually. 706 00:30:08,139 --> 00:30:09,374 - What do you mean, you guess? - I don't know. 707 00:30:09,440 --> 00:30:11,409 The rumor was that she ran away. 708 00:30:11,476 --> 00:30:12,710 Left in the middle of the night. 709 00:30:12,777 --> 00:30:14,612 No note. That kind of thing. 710 00:30:14,679 --> 00:30:16,614 Wilson was pretty broken up by it. 711 00:30:16,681 --> 00:30:19,184 I figured that's why he left town, to track her down. 712 00:30:19,250 --> 00:30:20,885 - You know how to get in contact with him? 713 00:30:20,952 --> 00:30:22,921 - No, that was a part of the deal 714 00:30:22,987 --> 00:30:24,889 when he agreed to rent me this place. 715 00:30:24,956 --> 00:30:26,291 I'm paying a reduced rate, 716 00:30:26,357 --> 00:30:28,593 but the upkeep of the house is on me. 717 00:30:28,660 --> 00:30:30,128 - Where do you send the rent? 718 00:30:30,195 --> 00:30:31,529 - I can get you the address. 719 00:30:31,596 --> 00:30:34,732 It's a PO box in a town called Nelsonville. 720 00:30:34,799 --> 00:30:37,702 [suspenseful music] 721 00:30:37,769 --> 00:30:43,107 ♪ ♪ 722 00:30:43,174 --> 00:30:44,709 - Hey, Jubal. - Yeah? 723 00:30:44,776 --> 00:30:46,377 - Yeah, the post office clerk confirmed 724 00:30:46,444 --> 00:30:47,879 Whalen's been checking his box regularly 725 00:30:47,946 --> 00:30:48,880 the last five months. 726 00:30:48,947 --> 00:30:50,081 - That--that's great. 727 00:30:50,148 --> 00:30:51,449 Do they know where he's been staying? 728 00:30:51,516 --> 00:30:52,884 - No, but they have him on security cameras 729 00:30:52,951 --> 00:30:54,085 driving a green pickup truck. 730 00:30:54,152 --> 00:30:55,286 You'll get the footage soon. 731 00:30:55,353 --> 00:30:57,855 - Yeah, got it. Downloading it now. 732 00:30:59,657 --> 00:31:01,459 - Okay. Okay. 733 00:31:03,728 --> 00:31:05,530 There's Whalen. 734 00:31:05,597 --> 00:31:12,437 ♪ ♪ 735 00:31:12,503 --> 00:31:14,038 Kelly, can you run these plates, please? 736 00:31:14,105 --> 00:31:17,508 318, Charlie, Hotel, Uniform, Romeo. 737 00:31:17,575 --> 00:31:19,210 - Okay. 738 00:31:19,277 --> 00:31:23,114 Green Chevy S-10, purchased for cash five months ago. 739 00:31:23,181 --> 00:31:24,482 Registered to Jim Wilson. 740 00:31:24,549 --> 00:31:26,451 - Do we have a way of tracking it? 741 00:31:26,517 --> 00:31:28,119 - It's a 2003 model. No GPS. - All right. 742 00:31:28,186 --> 00:31:29,887 Let's put a BOLO out on that vehicle, please. 743 00:31:29,954 --> 00:31:31,256 - I wanna get air support up there too. 744 00:31:31,322 --> 00:31:32,924 See if we can get eyes on it from above. 745 00:31:32,991 --> 00:31:35,893 [tense music] 746 00:31:35,960 --> 00:31:43,101 ♪ ♪ 747 00:31:50,575 --> 00:31:52,010 - Maggie, 10 o'clock. 748 00:31:56,214 --> 00:31:58,149 - Hey, Jubal. We've got eyes on Whalen. 749 00:31:58,216 --> 00:31:59,917 - All right, we got him. 750 00:31:59,984 --> 00:32:01,719 Get Putnam PD over there. We need backup. 751 00:32:01,786 --> 00:32:08,926 ♪ ♪ 752 00:32:30,415 --> 00:32:32,917 [tires squealing] 753 00:32:35,653 --> 00:32:37,255 - Jubal, Whalen made us. 754 00:32:37,322 --> 00:32:38,589 He's fleeing in that green pickup truck, 755 00:32:38,656 --> 00:32:40,825 heading east on Main Street. We're in pursuit. 756 00:32:40,892 --> 00:32:47,565 ♪ ♪ 757 00:33:13,124 --> 00:33:14,692 - Damn it! 758 00:33:16,761 --> 00:33:18,329 - All right, folks, Jeff Whalen is in the wind, 759 00:33:18,396 --> 00:33:19,664 and he knows we're on to him, 760 00:33:19,731 --> 00:33:21,366 which means we need to find him, and fast. 761 00:33:21,432 --> 00:33:23,000 Kelly, where are we with that truck? 762 00:33:23,067 --> 00:33:24,535 - Nothing yet, but we got the entire 763 00:33:24,602 --> 00:33:26,904 Putnam County Police Department out there looking for it. 764 00:33:26,971 --> 00:33:28,373 Air support two minutes out. 765 00:33:28,439 --> 00:33:30,041 - Any leads on where he's going? 766 00:33:30,108 --> 00:33:31,376 - If he's going to the post office regularly, 767 00:33:31,442 --> 00:33:33,378 he's gotta be living nearby. 768 00:33:33,444 --> 00:33:35,646 - We've been looking at recent property sales in the area. 769 00:33:35,713 --> 00:33:39,350 There was one about five months back that stands out. 770 00:33:39,417 --> 00:33:41,085 A small cabin way back in the woods 771 00:33:41,152 --> 00:33:42,620 on the outskirts of town. 772 00:33:42,687 --> 00:33:44,922 Buyer paid cash the same day Whalen emptied his accounts 773 00:33:44,989 --> 00:33:46,124 and left Poughkeepsie. 774 00:33:46,190 --> 00:33:48,192 - Was his name on the deed? - No. 775 00:33:48,259 --> 00:33:50,194 House was purchased under the name Joe Woodman. 776 00:33:50,261 --> 00:33:52,630 So we're into a bit of guesswork there. 777 00:33:52,697 --> 00:33:55,833 - Okay, but we know Whalen has changed his name in the past, 778 00:33:55,900 --> 00:33:57,135 and the initials are consistent. 779 00:33:57,201 --> 00:33:58,970 Jeff Whalen, Jim Wilson, Joe Woodman. 780 00:33:59,036 --> 00:34:00,938 - It's gotta be him. - Yeah. 781 00:34:01,005 --> 00:34:02,673 - Jubal, get SWAT and both teams over 782 00:34:02,740 --> 00:34:05,276 to that address, now. - Yes, ma'am. 783 00:34:05,343 --> 00:34:06,778 - Where are you going? 784 00:34:06,844 --> 00:34:08,446 - To Nelsonville. 785 00:34:15,286 --> 00:34:18,222 [tense music] 786 00:34:18,289 --> 00:34:22,260 ♪ ♪ 787 00:34:22,326 --> 00:34:23,860 - Hey. How's it looking? 788 00:34:23,928 --> 00:34:25,596 - No sign of Whalen, but we're definitely in the right spot. 789 00:34:25,663 --> 00:34:27,063 Green truck is parked on the side. 790 00:34:27,130 --> 00:34:28,565 - All right, let's send a scout to get eyes on him. 791 00:34:28,632 --> 00:34:30,668 But stay out of sight until we're ready to move in. 792 00:34:30,735 --> 00:34:32,469 - Yes, ma'am. - Copy. 793 00:34:32,536 --> 00:34:34,871 - Jubal, Whalen's truck's on site. 794 00:34:34,938 --> 00:34:38,109 I wanna get a team into that house as soon as possible. 795 00:34:38,176 --> 00:34:39,944 How are you on your side? - Air support is up. 796 00:34:40,011 --> 00:34:41,545 We have an aerial view of the property, 797 00:34:41,612 --> 00:34:43,915 and Elise has blueprints for the house. 798 00:34:43,981 --> 00:34:45,583 - All right. Can we get a copy to OA? 799 00:34:45,650 --> 00:34:46,984 - Yeah, sending now. 800 00:34:47,051 --> 00:34:48,553 - We've got several acres of woods 801 00:34:48,619 --> 00:34:49,853 in between you and the next property. 802 00:34:49,920 --> 00:34:51,222 We need to get that contained. 803 00:34:51,289 --> 00:34:53,558 - How long before we have the manpower for that? 804 00:34:53,623 --> 00:34:54,659 - Scola and Tiffany are on their way 805 00:34:54,725 --> 00:34:57,228 with a second SWAT team. 806 00:34:57,295 --> 00:35:00,465 - Isobel, we might have a problem. 807 00:35:00,531 --> 00:35:01,866 - Jubal, hang on. What's going on? 808 00:35:01,933 --> 00:35:02,967 - Whalen may know that we're here. 809 00:35:03,034 --> 00:35:04,535 Scouts got eyes on him. 810 00:35:04,602 --> 00:35:06,971 He retreated into the house, closed the curtains. 811 00:35:07,038 --> 00:35:08,473 - So much for the element of surprise. 812 00:35:08,539 --> 00:35:10,141 - So let's switch gears. 813 00:35:10,208 --> 00:35:13,044 Wait for backup, treat it like a hostage negotiation. 814 00:35:13,110 --> 00:35:14,779 - No, no, the longer we let this boil, 815 00:35:14,846 --> 00:35:16,247 the worse it gets for Annabelle. 816 00:35:16,314 --> 00:35:18,015 We've gotta stop him before he does something rash. 817 00:35:18,082 --> 00:35:19,784 - Hang on. Whoa, whoa. Think about it for a minute. 818 00:35:19,851 --> 00:35:21,719 - We don't have a minute, Jake. 819 00:35:21,786 --> 00:35:23,955 Whalen is a loose cannon. 820 00:35:24,021 --> 00:35:25,823 Maggie, OA, we're going in now. - Got it. 821 00:35:25,890 --> 00:35:32,997 ♪ ♪ 822 00:35:40,838 --> 00:35:43,174 - Bravo team, go. 823 00:35:47,912 --> 00:35:49,280 Alpha team, on me. 824 00:36:06,163 --> 00:36:07,331 - OA! 825 00:36:07,398 --> 00:36:14,305 ♪ ♪ 826 00:36:34,659 --> 00:36:35,960 Hey! 827 00:36:36,727 --> 00:36:37,895 Hey! 828 00:36:46,037 --> 00:36:49,507 [both grunting] 829 00:36:58,482 --> 00:36:59,750 - Where's the girl? 830 00:36:59,817 --> 00:37:00,985 - I couldn't just let her leave! 831 00:37:01,052 --> 00:37:02,620 She's my daughter. 832 00:37:02,687 --> 00:37:04,088 I love her. 833 00:37:04,155 --> 00:37:07,158 She was my little baby! - Where is she? 834 00:37:07,224 --> 00:37:09,327 - We were supposed to be together forever. 835 00:37:09,393 --> 00:37:10,695 I love her. 836 00:37:10,761 --> 00:37:12,697 - Hey. Hey. 837 00:37:12,763 --> 00:37:14,165 Where is she? - Isobel, we have him. 838 00:37:14,231 --> 00:37:15,366 We're bringing him back now. 839 00:37:15,433 --> 00:37:16,901 Let's go. 840 00:37:18,803 --> 00:37:20,271 - Nice job, you two. 841 00:37:20,338 --> 00:37:21,839 Dan, how's the search of the house coming? 842 00:37:21,906 --> 00:37:22,974 Any sign of Annabelle? 843 00:37:23,040 --> 00:37:25,443 - Negative. The house is clear. 844 00:37:25,509 --> 00:37:26,944 Let's move out. 845 00:37:27,011 --> 00:37:28,212 - There's no way. 846 00:37:28,279 --> 00:37:30,081 Annabelle is the only family Whalen has. 847 00:37:30,147 --> 00:37:32,550 He's too attached to her to not have her with him. 848 00:37:32,617 --> 00:37:33,851 Keep searching that house, Dan. 849 00:37:33,918 --> 00:37:35,553 She's gotta be there. 850 00:37:35,620 --> 00:37:36,487 - We can do another sweep. 851 00:37:36,554 --> 00:37:43,127 ♪ ♪ 852 00:37:59,543 --> 00:38:00,845 - What the hell? 853 00:38:04,181 --> 00:38:06,517 - Dan, talk to me. Are you guys okay? 854 00:38:06,584 --> 00:38:07,985 - Gas line exploded. 855 00:38:08,052 --> 00:38:09,820 Whalen must have untethered it. Everybody out, now! 856 00:38:09,887 --> 00:38:11,422 - Wait, what about the girl? 857 00:38:11,489 --> 00:38:12,757 - She isn't here. We have to clear out. 858 00:38:12,823 --> 00:38:13,824 There's gas everywhere. 859 00:38:13,891 --> 00:38:14,992 The whole place is gonna go up. 860 00:38:15,059 --> 00:38:18,796 [officers shouting] 861 00:38:18,863 --> 00:38:20,097 - That's everyone. - No, no. 862 00:38:20,164 --> 00:38:21,399 They--they don't have Annabelle. 863 00:38:21,465 --> 00:38:22,466 We've gotta find her. 864 00:38:24,702 --> 00:38:26,170 - Are you out of your mind? 865 00:38:26,237 --> 00:38:28,005 They swept the place. She isn't here. 866 00:38:28,072 --> 00:38:29,507 - No, she has to be. 867 00:38:29,573 --> 00:38:31,175 Annabelle means everything to Whalen. 868 00:38:31,242 --> 00:38:33,277 - Hey, Izzy. It's suicide. 869 00:38:33,344 --> 00:38:35,680 - We let her down once, and I will not do it again. 870 00:38:35,746 --> 00:38:42,887 ♪ ♪ 871 00:38:47,558 --> 00:38:48,926 Annabelle? 872 00:38:52,496 --> 00:38:54,331 [wood splintering] 873 00:39:05,476 --> 00:39:06,944 Annabelle? 874 00:39:14,785 --> 00:39:15,986 Annabelle? 875 00:39:23,294 --> 00:39:27,131 - [panting, coughing] 876 00:39:27,198 --> 00:39:30,935 - Annabelle, I'm with the FBI. 877 00:39:31,001 --> 00:39:32,536 I'm gonna get you out of here, okay? 878 00:39:32,603 --> 00:39:35,539 [coughing] 879 00:39:35,606 --> 00:39:42,546 ♪ ♪ 880 00:40:19,884 --> 00:40:22,987 [sentimental music] 881 00:40:23,053 --> 00:40:30,194 ♪ ♪ 882 00:40:32,363 --> 00:40:36,567 - Tasha, this is your mother, Joan Collier. 883 00:40:41,372 --> 00:40:43,274 - I'm sorry, I didn't-- 884 00:40:45,309 --> 00:40:47,111 He told me you were dead. 885 00:40:48,546 --> 00:40:50,447 - Mm. Hmm. Mm-hmm. 886 00:40:53,584 --> 00:40:57,388 - You two have a lot to catch up on, so take your time. 887 00:40:57,454 --> 00:40:59,456 When you're ready, we're here to help. 888 00:41:02,259 --> 00:41:05,629 We're gonna get you through this, okay? 889 00:41:05,696 --> 00:41:06,964 - Thank you. 890 00:41:07,031 --> 00:41:14,171 ♪ ♪ 891 00:41:27,151 --> 00:41:30,287 - [sobbing] 892 00:41:44,735 --> 00:41:46,604 - How's Annabelle doing? 893 00:41:46,670 --> 00:41:47,538 - She's okay. 894 00:41:47,605 --> 00:41:49,240 She's, uh trying to process. 895 00:41:49,306 --> 00:41:50,908 You know, make sense of everything. 896 00:41:50,975 --> 00:41:55,946 - Izzy, what you did, running into that house, was-- 897 00:41:56,013 --> 00:41:58,115 - Insane? 898 00:41:58,182 --> 00:41:59,383 - Yeah. 899 00:42:01,518 --> 00:42:03,454 We should--we should go out and celebrate 900 00:42:03,520 --> 00:42:04,855 and have a couple of drinks. 901 00:42:04,922 --> 00:42:05,990 For old time's sake. 902 00:42:06,056 --> 00:42:09,627 - Mm, no. 903 00:42:09,693 --> 00:42:10,828 I don't think so. 904 00:42:16,467 --> 00:42:19,069 [sighs] 905 00:42:19,136 --> 00:42:22,740 - Well, it was really good to see you. 906 00:42:22,806 --> 00:42:29,747 ♪ ♪ 907 00:42:42,559 --> 00:42:45,362 [dramatic music] 908 00:42:45,429 --> 00:42:52,369 ♪ ♪ 909 00:43:01,712 --> 00:43:03,380 [wolf howls] ic]